By MEG JONES
of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel staff
A Minnesota man thwarted while shoplifting merchandise from a St. Croix Falls Wal-Mart would not be denied, according to police.
He stole his haul a second time, police say - from the St. Croix Falls police station.
“You’d think a police department would be sacred grounds for a burglar, but not in this case,” St. Croix Falls Police Chief Paul Lindholm said Monday.
James J. Casarez, 36, of Willernie, Minn., is charged with one count of felony burglary to the police station in addition to misdemeanor retail theft and resisting an officer stemming from the shoplifting incident. Extradition proceedings are under way to bring him back to Wisconsin.
While some crimes are more difficult to solve than others, Lindholm said this case didn’t require much detective work.
Casarez was arrested by St. Croix Falls police on accusations of shoplifting an expensive toy car, more than $100 in over-the-counter medication, lithium batteries, a pellet pistol and a flip phone at Wal-Mart on June 24. He was booked into the jail and released the next day.
When Lindholm arrived at work at 6:30 a.m. on June 26, he noticed that someone had shattered a large window at the police station with a landscaping rock.
“We were very shocked. I kind of know how a victim of a crime feels when I walked in and saw the mess,” said Lindholm, who has been chief of St. Croix Falls, 70 miles northwest of Eau Claire, for 12 years.
The burglar ignored computer equipment, ammunition, radios and other valuable items, taking only a 3-by-4-foot cardboard box containing the items that Casarez had been accused of shoplifting from Wal-Mart.
“In fact, as he came through the window he stepped on a brand new assault rifle in a box,” Lindholm said. It was “a $700 assault rifle he could have taken out the door with him.”
Lindholm alerted law enforcement authorities in three Minnesota counties in the area of Casarez’s home. A convicted felon, Casarez was sitting in the Washington County, Minn., jail when authorities learned of the Wisconsin incidents.
About two weeks later, a Washington County, Minn., detective saw in Casarez’s front yard a toy all-terrain vehicle, big enough for a small child to ride and the same kind stolen from the St. Croix Falls Wal-Mart and police station. When Lindholm went to the jail to interview Casarez, who was in custody on charges of burglarizing a sporting cards store, he denied taking the items from the police station.
“He claims someone else had stolen it for his small child,” Lindholm said.
A few days later, an informant told Lindholm that Casarez had taken the shoplifted items from the police station, according to the criminal complaint.
Why would someone break into a police department and steal stolen stuff? Lindholm suspects that if it was indeed Casarez who broke into the station, Casarez wanted to get $1,000 in cash that was confiscated from his wallet when he was arrested outside Wal-Mart. Lindholm also noted that some of the items Casarez is accused of shoplifting are used to make methamphetamine.
Wal-Mart authorities noticed Casarez acting suspiciously inside the store and tried to stop him when he paid much less than the listed price for the battery-powered toddler’s ATV, which retails for almost $200.
“He had taken a UPC label off a $70 item and put it over that. So he had actually paid $70 for this $200 item,” Lindholm said.
When a police officer caught up to Casarez after a short foot chase outside Wal-Mart, he noticed the toy box had been slit open.
Inside, in addition to the toy, were a pellet pistol, a flip phone and “probably over $100 worth of Actifed and Sudafed, which is an ingredient for methamphetamines. Also some lithium batteries, which is also a piece of the pie when you’re cooking crystal meth,” Lindholm said.
Story courtesty the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.